Warbler Tips ID Chart
by Daniel Edelstein, danieledelstein@att.net, 415-382-1827
Warbler Tips ID Chart
(for selected N. America wood-warbler species among the 56 species that typically are present annually above Mexico)
by Daniel Edelstein, www.warblerwatch.com, edelstein@earthlink.net, 415-382-1827
SCIENTIFIC NAME | Common Name | SpringArrival Time | Fall Departure Time. | Confused With? | Breeding Habitat | Status | Comments | |
Setophaga petechia | Yellow | Early (among top 5) | July onward (early disperse after nesting) | Prothonotary | Deciduous bottom lands/creek bottoms; wet and/or or moist areas; dense vegetation | Decline in W. USA | 46 subspecies is most of all 115 New World wood-warblers; many endemics; largest geographical breeding area of all 115 New World wood-warblers: northern S. America to Alaska. | |
Setophaga pennsylvanica | Chestnut-sided | More eastern USA; protracted depature | Golden-winged | Deciduous; 2nd growth areas; absent from thick, dense, unbroken/unfragmented forest | Local declines in eastern USA where climax/dense forest has returned | Frequent B.H. Cowbird host; declines when mature forests return to an area; more rare during 1700s (when climax forests occurred) than now. | ||
Setophaga magnolia | Magnolia | Often early | Immature Prairie | Conif. forest; esp. spruce | Increases in New Engl. | “Spruce Warbler” would be apt name; it often nests in spruces | ||
Setophaga tigrina | Cape May |
|
Early | 1st year, female Yellow-Rumped | Conif. forest; bogs | Fluctuate; cyclical | Arboreal; “fighter,” often defend. food sources (fruit/nect) | |
Setophaga caerulescens | Black-Throated Blue | Late | Female with Orange-Crowned & Tennessee | Deciduous & mixed woods | On “Watch List” | Nests in decid. or mixed woods; Highly dimorphic (male-female) | ||
Setophaga virens | Black-Throated Green | Golden-cheeked; Town/Hermit hybrids | conifif/mixed woods | Varies yearly | Winters in second growth/edges, thus able to survive deforestat. | |||
Setophaga dominica | Yellow-throated | Very early | Early | Grace´s | Low. forest; Sp. moss imp | Expanding N and E? | Creeping foraging behavior is tell-tale clue; often up high | |
Setophaga pinus | Pine | Early | Late | Fall Blackpoll,Bay-breasted | Pines, other conifs. | Stable in S. range (?) | Large, long-tailed, heavy-billed; dist. trill; among hardiest warbs. | |
Setophaga kirtlandii | Kirtland´s | Late? | Palm & Prairie (tail bobs) | Jack pines in MI and ? | On Fed. End. List | Rare; cowbird management and habitat management important | ||
Setophaga
discolor |
Prairie | Male Pine; fall Magnolia; Palm (tail bobs) | Successional habitats | On “Watch List” | BBS data shows recent declines over most of range | |||
Setophaga
castanea |
Bay-breasted | Long, extended | Fall Bay-breasted’s with Fall Blackpolls | Boreal forests | < when < mat. forests | Populations vary with yearly spruce budworm populations | ||
Setophaga striata | Blackpoll | Often late | More E. than sp´s | Fall with 1st fall Bay-breasted (especially females) | Wet conifers | Often abundant | Most highly-migratory wood warbler (2,150 miles autumn flight for east USA migrators) | |
Setophaga fusca | Blackburnian | Rel. early, E. | 1st fall female with Cerulean & immature female Townsend’s | Mixed forest; tall, mature conifers | Vulnerable due to hab. changes | Hemlocks often are nesting site; Usnea lichen often used in n. areas; spanish moss in s. USA | ||
Setophaga coronata
(S. c. coronata = Myrtle; S. c. auduboni = Audubon’s) |
Yellow-rumped | Early | Late | For both Audubon’s & Myrtle, a look-alike is 1st fall female Cape May | Conifers, mixed forests | BBS shows no trends | American Ornithology Society and Clements taxonomical nomenclature recognizes S. coronata species to include S. c. coronata = Myrtle and S. c. auduboni = Audubon’s as subspecies. Two subspp. interbreed in along a narrow portion in n. British Columbia and along border between B. Columbia and Alberta. | |
Setophaga
cerulea |
Cerulean | Early | One of earliest | Females and 1st fall males look like 1st fall female Blackburnian | Old growth, mature deciduous forests | Numbers down; On “Watch List” | BBS suggests major drops in breeding bird populations. Degradation of both winter. and summer habitats | |
SCIENTIFIC NAME | Common Name | SpringArrival Time | Fall Departure Time. | Confused With? | Breeding Habitat | Status | Comments | ||||
Vermivora pinus | Blue-winged
|
Early | Usually early | Hybrids/intergrades with Golden-winged (Brewster’s and Lawrence’s intergrades), in addition to Yellow, Prothonotary, Orange-Crowned (subspecies lutescens) | Wide variety successional: old pastures, woodland clearings, powerline openings & slashings | N, NE expansion | May mate w/ Golden-winged warbler; resulting shared field marks create Brewster’s or Lawrence’s” warbler | ||||
V.
chrysoptera |
Golden-winged | Typical Gulf Coast arrival is early April | Leaves after Blue-winged | Hybrids/intergrades with Golden-winged (Brewster’s and Lawrence’s intergrades), and, if viewed from below, the Black-throated Gray Warbler. | Successional habitats | On Watch List | BBS data indicates decline over most of its nesting range, northeastern and southern USA where long-term competition with Blue-winged Warbler results in this species displacing some populations of Golden-winged. | ||||
Oreothlypisperegrine | Tennessee | Often early | Orange-
crowned |
Boreal forests | Often varies yearly | Some females arrive on n. breeding grounds pregnant due to mating during migration | |||||
Oreothlypisruficapilla | Nashville | Early
|
Often early | Variety | Stable? | Two distinct subspecies; one in both E & W USA | |||||
Parula
americana |
No. Parula | Very early | Pro-
longed |
Nashville | Varies | Stable? | Breeds high in trees, often using lichens or Spanish moss as nesting material | ||||
Mniotilta
varia |
Black-and-white | Early | Very early | Blackpoll | Mature & 2nd Growth | Regional declines; cowbird par | Creeping foraging is often diagnostic; glean trunks/branches for larvae/insects | ||||
Setophaga
ruticilla |
American Redstart | Often late | Pro-longed | Distinct’vappr’nce | Wet decid, mixed for. | Fewer: pts of range | Tame/curious; squeaks/”pishes” attract this warbler that acts like may act like flycatcher | ||||
Protonotaria
citrea |
Prothonotary | Early | Very early exit | Yellow, Blue-winged | Bottom-land forests | Numbers down; On “Watch List” | Prefers dark, damp lowland woods, swamps; found in wet, shady areas; snags/stumps essential for nesting cavities; only E. USA cavity-nesting wood-warbler | ||||
Helmitheros
vermivorus |
Worm-eating | Early | Swain-
son’s |
Decid. or mixed woods | Numbers down; On “Watch List” | On migration, may feed higher in treetops than in breeding areas where it forages low, often in clusters of dead leaves; hops, doesn’t walk; usually uses ground for nest | |||||
Limnothlypis
swainsonii |
Swainson’s | Worm-eating | Wet woods; cane sp. | Numbers down; On “Watch List” | Rare;wooded swamplands and canebrakes of SE lowlands and rhododendron thickets; Shy and reclusive; excellent place to see:
Dismal Swamp in SE Virgina |
||||||
Seirus
aurocapillus |
Ovenbird | Pro-
longed |
N. & LA Waterthr. | Mature forests | Hurt by forest fragmentation | Thrush-like warbler’s “teacher-teacher” song heard in deciduous/mixed forest of boreal E. No. Am; common name comes from domed ground nest (Dutch oven) | |||||
Parkesia
motacilla |
Louisiana
Waterthrush |
Among earliest | Among earl., if not 1st | No. Waterth. | Fast flow./ rocky streams | No strong pop. trends | More SE breeding range than No. Water.; early spring arrival/fall departure; note white throat as a good field mark to distinguish from buffy-throated No. Water. | ||||
SCIENTIFIC NAME | Common Name | SpringArrival Time | Fall Departure Time. | Confused With? | Breeding Habitat | Status | Comments |
Geothlypis
formosus |
Kentucky | Common Yellowthroat | Deep decid. woods & fewer in mixed woods | Sensitive to fragment; on “Watch List” | Spends most of the time on or near ground; indicator of forest “health” because it uses lg. decid. forests, mostly in South/Mid-Atlantic | ||
Oporonis
Agilis |
Connecticut | Very late | Among latest to leave | Mourning | Varies | More numerous in 19th C. | May be latest arriving spring warbler in E.; secretive; walking gait is like ovenbird’s |
Geothlypis
philadelphia |
Mourning | Among latest arrivals | Often begins early | Mac-
gillivary’s |
Boreal habs.; Dense 2nd growth | Stable? | Closely related and looks like Macgillivary’s; confused with Conn. & F. Common Yellowthroats |
Geothlypis
trichas |
Common
Yellowthroat |
|
Kentucky in N. NA & Y’llthr’t spp. | Damp, weedy marshy, brush hab’t’s | Stable; but declines in S. & W. | Fifteen subspecies recognized by some researchers; wide geographic variation (approaches Yell. W’s) | |
Setophaga
citrina |
Hooded | Often begins early | Lawrence’s
(hybrid of Bl wi/gold wi) |
Up & b’tl’nd woodlands | Stable | Distinctive black & yellow hood; largest eye among 32 warblers as “tool” to live in shady habitats | |
Cardellina
pusilla |
Wilson’s | Female Hooded | Dense, wet ground cover | Local declines & increases | More common in W. than E.; 3 subspecies; Extremely active behavior; hovers/sallies like flycat’s | ||
Cardellina
canadensis |
Canada | Among latest arrivals | Early | Kentucky (in face); F. is like Nashville | Cool, moist woods, swamps | Declines in portion of range; cowbird para. com | Obvious eye-ring and “necklace” are key field marks; forages like flycatchers with “sally”; inquisitive and active; often found with Wilson’s during migration |
Parkesia
noveboracen-sis |
Northern Waterthrush | Early | Louisiana Waterth. | Woods w/ slow H20 | Stable?
S. pops lower? |
Distinguished from Louis. Waterth. by buffy/gray throat, bill size, supercilium shape | |
Setophaga
palmarum |
Palm | early in E/MidW | More E. than spri. | Prairie,
Kirtland’s |
Bogs, wood margins | Stable, except FL | Continuous tail-pumping; often lives in open, unwooded habitats |
HOME